The sub-laptop niche. What’s happening there?
October 28, 2007
The space in the market below a full laptop running Windows is being squeezed more and more as the price of a Win XP laptop falls. The most successful device in this niche has been the minimalist Alphasmart range. From the original Alphasmart, the 2000, the 3000 and now the Neo (pictured above) they have been the device that offered the least in terms of features. The Dreamwiter had far better spellchecking; The more expensive Windows CE (Compact Edition) had the good quality spellchecker in MS Word; but these have Even the Alphasmart Dana with smaller text has not really caught on very well.
The Alphasmart 3000 could be bought with the predictive typer; Co: Writer, which made it a more useful tool for some pupils with literacy difficulties. The most recent model, the Neo has overcome, to some extent the problem of the small amount of text visible within the screen, by offering smaller text. The text that you could see on the screen has been 4 lines of 40 characters. The Neo offers a range of options - including 6 lines of 52 characters.
The Alphasmart range probably owes its longevity to its simplicity, long battery life and lightness. They give a good amount of work for three AA batteries.
All these devices have had a great advantage over al Windows laptop that they are ready to use very quickly. There is a start-up time of only a couple of seconds and you can be writing. In the school situation, this is a very important advantage.
There is a newcomer in the sub-laptop niche which may prove to be very useful long term.

The RM Asus Mini notebook. should be available from November 2007. It is a small laptop with a small screen 7 “, where a laptop might have a 12″ or greater screen.
How can it be so cheap? Well it runs Linux the cost-free open source operating system. The main software installed is Open Office - a free equivalent to MS Office. It will read and save files with the .doc (MS Word) , .xls (Excel) and ppt formats. The Firefox browser is installed and there is wi-fi connectivity. However, it is not clear how pupils will gain access to the internet through school networks.
Pupils will probably transfer their files to a standalone or networked computer using a USB memory stick (pendrive).
From the point of view of supporting pupils with literacy difficulties, there is not much good news in this development. The Alphasmarts have always had a poor spell-checker compared with MS Word - See the CALL Centre report. From a brief trial of the spell-checker in Open Office - it manages almost as well as MS word on the errors below by pupil with a mild spelling difficulty. On the other hand, using my favourite test sentence “I liyk to vist forin playsis”, it does not perform nearly so well. Also, there does not seem to be any way of having a talking word processor. There seems to be no option to add software that might become available.
The Mini Notebook reads SD cards ( used in many digital cameras) and comes with some picture editing and sound editing software. Useful for creative work!
The RM Asus Mini Notebook is definitely aimed at the almost the same price range as the Neo. It could gradually push the Neo out. However, if the Neo’s price is reduced, it may continue to survive in this niche. I’d certainly welcome that!
All the above comes from reading. More, if and when I get my hands on one. Any comments form anyone who had had some experience of one. Details of how much use you get between battery charges would be very useful.
The best review I have found is here; http://www.notebookreview.com/default.asp?newsID=4044
Certainly the screen looks really good. However the keyboard does not sound very good. The small size may suit children better than adults. One thing to note; what is being reviewed here is not the actual RM version which will be marketed at schools. There may be significant differences - especially in terms of memory size. Take care before ordering.
Posted by ictsan

